You're using a bunch of ifs then an else:

if 1
if 2
if 3
if 4
if 5
else

That else only takes note of the most recent if, so if if you're not if5, you're going to become else, regardless of the other ifs. Because the other ifs might change you, but the else at the bottom will change you back. You need to use else ifs like this:

if
else if
else if
else if
else if
else