The Obama Administration has recently
weighed in on damages for copyright violations of up to $150,000
per violation.
Whether you are pro-piracy or anti-piracy, I think we can all agree that the idea of download
one mp3 causes
$150,000 in damages to the music industry is absolutely ludicrous. By stealing one song, you have apparently caused damage worth of 15 thousand times the cost of the average CD, or
one hundred and fifty thousand times the cost of the song if you bought the individual mp3 on Amazon or iTunes or what have you.
Let's do some math. Right now, the second most popular music torrent on ThePirateBay is the entire Pink Floyd discography. There's 777 files in that torrent, but there's lots of album art so for the sake of easiness, let's assume 277 files are JPGs and 500 are mp3s. This torrent currently has 1,226 seeds (for the non-torrenters: a seed is someone who has the complete set of data, i.e. all the files). While it's obvious that seeds are only a small fraction of everyone who has downloaded this torrent (most people stop seeding immediately after downloading, or once they have reached an upload:download ratio of 1.000).
So we can say there's 500 mp3s which have been downloaded by at least 1226 people.
500 songs * 1226 people = 613000 counts of copyright violation
613000 counts * 150000 USD = $91,950,000,000 USD
Almost
Ninety Two Billion Dollars worth of damages from one torrent.
Do you see how this doesn't add up? According to the IFPI (which from what I understand is like the UK RIAA), the
global music industry is worth
130 billion dollars.
So what these nutjobs would like you to believe is the damage done by that one torrent on ThePirateBay has is more than 70% of their worth. Interesting...
[edit 1]
Actually, it seems that there was 431 jpg files in that torrent (jeez, album art much?), so that brings the music down to only 346 songs. Even so, this is still $63,629,400,000, nearly half the net worth of the global music industry.
[edit 2]
For anyone who wants to pull out the "Yeah, but they said ranging from $750 to $150,000", I'll give you this:
The private music torrent tracker what.cd has had 14,239,659 "snatches" (downloads). A snatch counts only the download of the torrent, not all the files within. What.cd does not have discographies, usually just albums (some singles, too, sure). If even the average snatch had 5 songs, you're talking about $53,398,721,250 USD in damages from
one private torrent tracker (math: snatches * 750 usd-per-song * 5 songs-per-snatch = 14239659*750*5).
[edit 3]
Furthermore, according to
this video, produced by
Sony BMG, 694,000 songs are downloaded every five minutes. This means that 138,800 are downloaded every minute, which means that 199,872,000 songs are downloaded every day. Apply the minimum figure of $750 per violation and you see that $149,904,000,000 USD in damages are done daily. Use that maximum $150,000 figure, you see that $2.99808 × 10
13 USD (That's $29,980,800,000,000 or almost thirty trillion dollars) in damages are done
daily.
You can understand why I don't care about any figures thrown around by the IFPI, RIAA, MPAA, and all like them. It's propaganda, and when you start putting it all together, you can see how ridiculous it is.
Posted by Airjoe on Tuesday, March 24, 2009 08:20PM
- 78 comments
(link)
/
Members say:
yea +2,
nay -1
(Edited on Tuesday, March 24, 2009 08:57PM)