Descriptive Problem Summary:
BYOND Guilds have an option to allow the guild to receive applications from members, but not auto-accept them. When this happens, the applications end up in the submissions tab, with two buttons. When pressing the reject button, a pop-up appears that asks for a reason, with an "okay" button and a "cancel" button. Pressing the cancel button causes the application to be rejected anyway.

Numbered Steps to Reproduce Problem:
Turn on Guild applications, do not auto-accept applications.
Have someone submit a request to join the guild.
Click reject on the submission.
Then press cancel to leave the pop-up.

Expected Results:
Submission remains in-tact, as though no action had been performed on it.

Actual Results:
Submission is rejected.

Does the problem occur:
Every time? Or how often? Every time.
In other user accounts? Yes.
On other computers? Yes.

Workarounds:
Be really careful what you click when handling guild join applications.