One of my games isn't being "featured" but I don't know why. It doesn't have any "illegal" content so it must not have enough quality. Seems like BYOND should provide feedback where it's a matter of opinion. The feedback can be "canned" but something which helps us improve our game Vs. "you and your game suck, sorry".
As described by List Guidelines:
These are the requirements for a game to be featured:
* This game should have high quality.
* The content should not involve another person's intellectual property (i.e., fan games cannot be featured).